Bariatric Surgery Practice Opportunities, Bariatric Surgery jobs, ASMBS Corporate Council Member, Obesity Surgery, Gastric Bypass, Laparoscopic Surgery, Obesity Surgery, Morbid Obesity, Body Mass Index, Bariatric Surgeon jobs, Bariatric Program Coordinator jobs, Bariatric Nurse jobs, Bariatric Surgery Practice Opportunities, Bariatrician
The Economics of Bariatric Surgery Program
Bariatric Surgery Program Survey Results
By: Susan Coleman, Vice-President, ESA Medical Resources
First of all, thank you to everyone who participated in ESA Medical Resources’ first Bariatric Surgery Program Survey. We received some great feedback which we will share with you here. If you did not have a chance to give us your feedback, you may still go to our blogsite: www.blog.esamedicalresources.com and take our survey. The more input from you, the better! We will follow up on your questions, concerns and suggestions in subsequent online newsletters.
I think that the headline of this survey is that the vast majority of respondents are very pleased that they made the decision to establish a bariatric practice/program, but they are very displeased with the insurance reimbursement process. Let’s take a closer look at the responses to each question:
Question 1: Given the challenges of running a quality bariatric surgery program, are you pleased that you undertook this endeavor with 1 being very displeased and 10 being very pleased?
The mean or average response to this question was 8.77 (with a range of 3 to 10). Almost half of respondents rated this question a 10. On the whole, you are glad you chose this much-needed specialty.
Question 2: How do you feel about the process of third party payor reimbursement with 1 being very displeased and 10 being completely satisfied?
The average of responses here was 3.26 (with a range of 1 to 8). Twenty-five percent of you rated this area a 1. On the whole you are very unhappy with this process.
Question 3: Has your program met the financial goals you set for it with 1 meaning very disappointed and 10 meaning expectations were exceeded?
This response mean was 6.03 (with a range of 1 to 9). While you are not on the whole displeased with financial outcomes, you certainly see opportunity to improve the revenue/expense balance. This is connected, of course, to insurance reimbursement. Some of you are pursuing more of the self-pay market.
Question 4: Are there any issues you would like to see resolved that would improve your financial outcomes?
Not surprisingly given the responses to Question 2, the overwhelming majority expressed concerns about the process of insurance reimbursement. Much criticism centered on the “hassle” (a term used in several surveys) of the pre-approval process.
One respondent expressed frustration at receiving an authorization number only to be told later that the authorization was given in error and therefore was withdrawn.
Another respondent stated that at times insurance companies can take 7 to 12 months to get a patient approved.
Another respondent criticized the staff hours required to “resubmit, resubmit, resubmit” insurance claims.
Many of you disagree with the requirements of 6 to 12 months of diets prior to approval and up to 5 years of documented BMIs. According to the Surgical Review Corporation’s website, Aetna, effective February 2008, dropped the 5 year requirement to 2 years which should be helpful. Again, according the SRC website, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan has reduced its 12-month diet timeframe to 6 months and has waived this requirement altogether for super obese, high-risk patients with a BMI ≥ 50.
Question 5: Is there anything you would do differently to improve your patient care outcomes?
Nearly half of respondents replied that there was nothing they would do differently. One responded: “We are doing everything we can think of.” Here are some other responses:
Question 6: If you could ask administrators from other programs any question, what would you ask?
Several respondents wanted to ask others in the industry how to best/most efficiently manage the patient through the entire process, starting with insurance approval and continuing through follow-up tracking. This question had many varied responses:
Question 7: Is there any bariatric surgery program data or information that you would like to have?
Follow-up on this survey will be two-pronged. First of all, please utilize ESA’s blogsite: www.blog.esamedicalresources.com to communicate with one another. You can begin discussions sharing successes and even failures on a variety of salient issues. Secondly, I will contact experts in the field of bariatric medicine, including our own consultants, to obtain answers to many of your questions and concerns. On the issue of insurance, in the short-term, we are operating within a given set of constraints, but I will try to obtain as much information as I can, to help you operate in the most efficient and profitable way possible within these parameters. I will communicate with bariatric industry advocates like the SRC and ASMBS to get their insight on how the insurance industry may be evolving and (hopefully) improving as more data is gathered through their BOLD initiative.
Please look for upcoming newsletters from ESA Medical Resources which will provide you with information concerning the issues you have indicated are important to you. Again, thank you for taking time from your very busy schedules to respond to our survey. If you have any questions please feel free to contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org
Copyrighted 2005-2017, ESA Medical Resources and Content Partners, All Rights Reserved-